One week to go…the debt ceiling debate

July 28, 2011

Raquel Frye

The hottest news story these days is the August 2nd deadline to raise the debt ceiling. The deadline has been set by the Treasury department because after this date, it cannot guarantee payment of all the government’s billions of dollars in monthly obligations.   In other words, if the amount that the U.S. is allowed to borrow is not increased, the nation will not be able to pay its bills.  To put things into perspective, the current debt limit (or ceiling) is set at 14.3 trillion dollars.   We actually hit that limit earlier this year and are currently relying on temporary measures to get around this technicality.    If the U.S. is not able to borrow more money, it will have to choose which obligations to pay.  The list of obligations is long and includes things such as Social Security benefits, interest payments on the national debt, Medicaid and Medicare payments, unemployment benefits as well as federal worker and military salaries.  As you can imagine, trying to decide what is the priority in that list is extremely difficult.

The possibility of the nation defaulting on payments has not gone unnoticed.  Moody’s Investors Service—the credit rating agency—is threatening to reduce the U.S. government’s Aaa bond rating if the debt ceiling is not raised and the nation defaults on its obligations.  Nobody can really foresee what the impact of a credit rating downgrade would mean for the economy.  Some speculate that the downgrade would have very little impact as much of the U.S. debt is held by pension funds and central banks that are not heavily influenced by rating agencies.  On the other hand, others agree that a downgrade could mean a weaker dollar and higher interest rates which could spell trouble for the fragile economy.

Although dealing with the possibility of default is urgent, what is more important is dealing with the long-term problem of the national debt (which is why we need to borrow in the first place).  Just like households have had to make difficult decisions regarding their spending and debt over the last couple of years, the same thing must happen at the government level.  Making the process even more problematic, the government is trying to make difficult choices amid a tight and looming deadline.  Currently, there are two plans to raise the debt limit and cut the deficit:  one plan has been devised by the Republican House Majority Leader John Boehner and one from Democratic Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.  Several very daunting hurdles remain for both plans, but as of last night, Speaker John Boehner’s plan seemed to be nearing the number of votes necessary to pass the House (217).  If it does pass, the hard part will not be over.  The most challenging part will begin once the bill enters the Senate and encounters Senate Majority Harry Reid’s competing plan.

Photo Credit: Associated Press


Maryland’s Business Climate—the factors and how we rank!

July 20, 2011

Daraius

As I have written in the past, Maryland is viewed (fairly or unfairly) as having a poor or less than friendly business climate.  Some have suggested that Maryland’s motto is “If You Can Dream It, We Can Tax It” which is not exactly a ringing endorsement for a business friendly state.   First what determines the business climate and is someone or some entity measuring the business climate?

According the International Economic Development Council (IEDC), the essence of a business climate is “how states state, regional and local policies, relationships and local communities support business development.”   What are some of the major factors associated with a business climate according to IEDC?

Major Factors

1. Business and income tax levels
Business and income tax levels allow prospective businesses to gauge their investments when seeking places to expand or incorporate. According to the Tax Foundation’s 2011 State Business Tax Climate Index (8th Edition), “States with the best tax systems will be the most competitive in attracting new businesses and most effective at generating economic and employment growth.”

2. Workforce availability
This factor does not necessarily need to focus on the amount of able body individuals a state currently has but rather the skill level of those within the state. Maryland’s accessibility and continued efforts to support technology driven education will continue to make us a viable contender with other surrounding metro areas. The Kauffman Foundation (New Economy Index) commented on the technology driven workforce stating, “…(states with) a solid innovation infrastructure that fosters and supports technological innovation, and many(of the highly ranked states) have a good quality of life coupled with high levels of domestic and foreign immigration of highly skilled knowledge workers.”

3.  Energy costs
A hotbed issue right now, rising energy costs not only are seen harboring our monthly electric bills but also at the gas pumps. Continually rising energy costs are added into the final cost of a product, often assisting in the loss of possible consumers. Maryland currently is ranked in the Small Business and Entrepreneurship (SBE) Energy Cost Index (2010) as being one of the highest energy cost states along with New Jersey (rank 44), Washington, D.C. (rank 42), and Delaware (rank 38) overall.

4.  Market size
The Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development’s 2008 Kentucky Business Climate report
referred to this factor as “market access.” The more accessible the state can be to either employees via public transportation, or business imports we will continue to see a growth in those that wish to invest in developing within Maryland borders. Factors such as roadway miles, number of airports, and waterway access are just a few factors that attract new business to states.

5. Cost of living
Cost of living plays a crucial role in exhibiting key trends that will decide if a state has a “good” business climate. States with lower costs of living allow residents to feel the significant increase in their purchasing power as opposed to those states that have high costs of living, per IECD’s key findings.

Other Contributing Factors

  • Quality of life
  • Environmental regulation
  • Permitting, licensing, and various reporting regulations
  • Real estate costs and availability
  • Infrastructure
  • Access to financing and capital
  • Incentive
  • Quality of services

So how does Maryland measure up?

Factor Indication Rating/Rate
Business Tax Levels State Business Tax Climate Index 4.25 (Rank 44)
Workforce Availability New Economy Index 3rd (MA ranked 1, NJ-4, DE-6, PA-22)
Income Tax Levels (State) Comptroller of Maryland MD 2.00-6.25%
DE 2.2-6.95%
PA 3.07%
VA 2.0-5.75%
D.C. 4.0-8.5%
Energy Costs SBE Council Energy Cost Index 39 (tied with Maine, DE-38)
Cost of Living MERIC Composite Cost of Living 44 (VA-24, PA-32, DE-35, DC-50)

So it would seem that Maryland faces some challenges to its business climate, but at least our state motto is not Massachusetts’ motto “Our Taxes Are Lower than Sweden’s (For Most Tax Brackets)”.


Maryland, the deficit and the debt limit

June 21, 2011

Daraius

Many people have heard me state that Maryland’s economy is based on “Eds, Beds, Feds, and Meds,” and this is one of the reasons why Maryland has suffered comparatively less during this most recent recession.   However, this insulation from economic events may be coming to an end and may have a severe impact on Maryland’s economy. Maryland by virtue of geography has become the home of many federal agencies, and by virtue of its highly educated workforce Maryland has received a disproportionate share of federal funding in research, cyber-security, defense, medicine, and other areas.

While the debate in Washington rages regarding the role of government and the need to shrink it, we Marylanders should feel especially vulnerable.  The Federal government directly employs approximately 130,000 civilian or over 5% of Maryland’s labor force. Moreover, Maryland is home to eleven agencies as well as ten military installations with over 80,000 military personnel, and the state receives over 1.5 billion dollars in federal research dollars, over ten billion dollars in federal expenditures, and over twelve billion dollars in private sector contracting opportunities. Finally, numerous Maryland citizens work for the federal government in Washington, D.C. and Northern Virginia.

It has been estimated that for every federal job in Maryland, two other private sector jobs are created. These private sector jobs include IT contractors, teachers, retail clerks and other professions.

A 10% cut in federal employment could potentially  result in the loss of nearly 40,000 jobs in Maryland, or about 1.6% of the total workforce.

Moreover, the federal workforce tends to be older on average and therefore will likely have a higher salary. As a result, a 10% loss in jobs will also have a disproportionate impact on Maryland’s income tax collections of those federal workers who live in Maryland.

To lessen the state’s dependency on the federal government, Maryland needs to encourage the growth of private sector jobs and companies.  There are hurdles from public policy to perception regarding Maryland’s business climate and tax rates. Hopefully, this is outweighed by our highly educated workforce. According the Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation (DLLR), Maryland created only 4,400 net new private sector jobs between April 2010 and April 2011 (a growth rate of 0.2%), a very modest number, to say the least .

This growth rate suggests that Maryland is in a precarious position in these latest deficit and debt discussions. Maryland’s economy would perform better if the federal cuts were targeted towards entitlement programs—Medicare and Social Security, for example—rather than agencies (NIH, NIST, DoD, etc.) as cuts to entitlement programs would be felt nationwide while cuts to agencies would be more acutely felt in Maryland. While I am not advocating government for government’s sake, we Marylander’s need to be aware of just how closely tied our economy is to the Federal government.

Image credit: World Travel Guide


Class of 2011—an outlook on your job search!

May 18, 2011

Raquel Frye

Attention College graduates…tell your parents you are not moving back home!  With the spring semester coming to an end across the nation, a number of college students will soon be stepping out into the real world.   Undoubtedly, recent grads are feeling nervous entering a job market that was battered during the Great Recession. However, unlike the last four years, students have a reason to be optimistic.  According to the Executive Director of National Association of College and Employers (NACE), the job market for new college graduates is gaining momentum. For instance, employers are planning to hire 19.3 percent more new college graduates—with a starting average salary of $50,462—this year compared to the same time a year ago. This is by far one of the best spring outlooks since 2007, when employers increased hiring of new college graduates by 19.2 percent.

Also, don’t forget that possible job prospects could be sitting right under your nose.  If you are currently an intern at a company, it might be a good idea to ask for a full-time promotion.  According to a survey completed by NACE, employers recruited more than half of their interns to full-time positions. This marks the highest rate of intern-to-staff hiring in a decade.

TU students preparing for commencement next week!

Around Maryland, job fairs and job prospects are also starting to pick up speed.  According to an article by the Baltimore Sun, Loyola University and John Hopkins University have both seen an increase in employer interest for career fairs.  In fact, a record number of 130 employers attended Loyola’s spring career fair.  At Johns Hopkins, they have also seen an increase in employer participation at their own career fairs as well as on-campus interviews.

While job prospects may be brighter, we must also recognize that the economy is still fragile and your personal job market outlook also depends greatly on your major.  According to the president of CareerBuilder.com, in-demand majors include information technology, sales, finance and accounting – to name a few.  I would go out on a limb and say that economics majors are probably not doing too bad themselves.  After all, it’s a degree that can be tailored to a number of positions and jobs titles.  Regardless of your degree of choice, here’s hoping this year is brighter for all 2011 graduates!


Baltimore Horse Racing, a valued tradition and economic driver!

May 5, 2011

Daraius

Throughout the history of Baltimore and Maryland, there have been many long-standing traditions and venues that have gone by the wayside as well as many familiar faces we have lost.  Remember the days of streetcars running in Baltimore,  shopping at Hutzler’s department stores, going to the Enchanted Forest Theme Park , dining at Haussner’s  Restaurant surrounded by the vast number of paintings, attending a game at Memorial Stadium or even catching a glimpse of Mayor Schaeffer in and around the city?  In the land of pleasant living, the loss of these icons of our past makes us feel less special – as if a piece of us is gone for good.  Granted there may be new icons replacing these lost icons, but it is far from the same.

Every spring as the flowers bloom and the smell of fresh cut grass fills the air, all of Maryland becomes acutely aware that Preakness is around the corner.  This year will mark the 136th running of the Preakness Stakes at Pimlico.  While this event has become less about the actual horse race and more about an event to be seen at, it is still, at its essence, an important part of Maryland’s history as well as our national history.  It is after all, the second leg of the crown jewel of Thoroughbred horse racing, the Triple Crown.  Not only is this event nationally broadcasted, it generates a great deal of economic activity from the millineries to the horse breeders.  It is estimated that Preakness generates between $40 and $60 million dollars in economic activity annually. It also brings to the city anyone who is anyone in Baltimore’s (Maryland’s) social circles as well as college students who invade the infield more for the party than the horse race.  It is truly a unique Baltimore (Maryland) event.

While the Preakness Stakes is a highly visible event nationally and an economic boom to the industry, it just may not be enough by itself to continue to support the overall horse industry in Maryland.  Based upon published estimates, the economic impact of the horse industry is $1.6 billion, with over half of that generated through racing.   Every year, a renewed debate occurs regarding the status of the horse racing industry in Maryland.  Given the challenges the industry in Maryland faces, from larger purses in other states to the presence of slots and table games at these out of state horse racing venues, the industry is struggling.  This has manifested itself in the form of proposals to shorten the racing season as well as the closure of some venues.

While many may wonder whether horse racing in Maryland or Maryland’s horse industry fits in with our “Eds, Feds, Meds and Beds” economy, it not only fits in, it is one of the great icons that helps to define Baltimore and Maryland.  However, if we do not take deliberative action to preserve this industry, we may find that one of our last remaining icons is on the ash heap of history.


How high do gas costs have to get before we change our behavior?

April 4, 2011

Raquel Frye

The rising cost of oil and gas prices seems to be on everyone’s mind these days.  How can it not be when every time you go to the pump prices are slowly creeping upwards? Higher gas prices hurt us in many different ways.

  • Have you had sticker shock at the grocery store lately? Higher gas prices mean higher grocery bills since food producers and distributors have to bear the increased costs of transporting goods across the country.
  • Tried booking a vacation recently? Airlines, taxis and even cruises all pass on the higher cost of fuel to the consumers.
  • Even your home renovations are not safe! For example, nylon carpets are petroleum based and carpet packing is closely tied to the price of oil.   Some of the increased costs of raw materials for carpet manufacturers are inevitable passed on the consumer.
  • Higher oil prices also have political ramifications. As gasoline prices keep increasing, the administration faces pressure to expand domestic oil and gas production and reduce our reliance on imported oil.

Photo Credit: treehugger.com

Higher gas prices also mean a change in behavior.  We can’t be sure just how high gas prices will get, but there are some predictions about what the price would have to be in order for fundamental changes in consumer purchases, driving trends, car buying behavior and mass transportation use.  A new report from the American Public Transportation Association finds that

  • $4 per-gallon gas prices could result in an increase of 670 million public transit passenger trips.
  • If gas prices increase to $5 a gallon, that figure grows to an additional 1.5 billion passenger trips.

Economists tend to agree that increased gas prices generally only have a short-term impact on our behavior (remember the increased demand for hybrids back in 2008?).  There would need to be a prolonged period of high gas prices—some estimate more than six months—to really see a significant change in the behavior of Americans.

Experts disagree about exactly how high gas prices need to be for consumers to begin to significantly alter their demand for oil.  For example, Exxon Mobil Corp. CEO Rex Tillerson said Americans started cutting back in 2008 when gasoline hit $4.00 per gallon. This time around, analysts predict that the threshold is somewhere between $3.50 and $4.50.  A recent report by the Energy Information Administration (EIA) suggests that American motorists are not significantly cutting back demand in the face of higher prices at the pump. According to the report, the U.S. consumed an average of 9.1 million barrels per day of gasoline, up 1.2 percent from the same time period last year.  As of this week, the current national average is standing at about $3.548, just at the peak of the bottom of that threshold.  So tell me, have higher gas prices significantly impacted your behavior yet?

 


Orioles Opening Day: What’s the Economic Impact of Baseball in Baltimore?

March 31, 2011

Daraius

As spring begins, the smell of pine tar, the crack of the bat, the thump of a well-caught ball and the whoosh of ball thrown on a rope will be filling the air.  Orioles Opening day is just around the corner.  Prognosticators fill the airwaves with their picks and pans for the upcoming season.  Which teams will make it to the World Series and which new hot prospect will get a call to the big show are questions many excited fans are asking themselves.  While these questions have usually been decided to a degree by September and in many cases are a disappointment to most fans, hope springs eternal on opening day.  Ahead lies 162 ball games and every team has a chance to get to the World Series.

Outside of the feeling of “anything is possible this season” or “dream the impossible dream”, what does opening day mean for Baltimore in terms of dollars and cents? There are several ways to illustrate the economic impact of opening day in Baltimore.  Drawing upon some of my own past research as well as work that Towson University completed on behalf of the Maryland Stadium Authority, there are several interesting findings.

In one of my papers, I examined the cost-benefits of a baseball stadium to a city.  Obviously, a winning team will attract more fans and attendance will go up.  Based upon my research, I found that

if a team increases its current year’s winning percentage by 10%,
attendance would rise by approximately 9.6%.

If the team had a strong finish in the prior season, then that will also influence the current year’s attendance, but its impact on attendance is less than half of the current year’s winning percentage.  While I did not explicitly examine an opening day effect on attendance, I suspect that since the season is a blank canvas and fans are full of hope, outside of playoff games, opening day attendance is likely to be among the highest in a team’s season.

Photo Credit: MLB - Oriole Park @ Camden Yards

In a recent Towson University study, the economic impact of the Orioles was estimated in terms of Gross Domestic Product (GDP), employment and taxes.  Over the entire season, the estimated impact of attendance at Camden Yards on Maryland’s GDP is approximately $175 million, while an estimated 2,500 annual FTE jobs are supported and over $18 million in state and local taxes are generated.  Based upon these data and the Orioles’ 2010 Opening day attendance (48,891), the impact of Opening Day on Maryland’s economy is estimated to be 50 annual FTE jobs, $3.3 million in GDP and about $350K in state and local taxes.  However, this does not include the lost productivity due to the spike in absenteeism on Opening Day.  So as they say, “Play ball!”


TO TAX or TO CUT; that is the question

March 10, 2011

Daraius

Our nation and our state face enormous fiscal challenges ahead. The very essence of what government’s role should be is being questioned during these difficult economic times. Our nation is undergoing one of the most severe economic dislocations since the Great Depression and in the course of propping up the economy; the federal government has accumulated tremendous deficits. Moreover, many states have gotten used to the tax revenues generated from the pre-recession period but have yet to wean themselves off the spending patterns that grew to absorb those tax revenues. Many states find themselves with immense unfunded of underfunded pension and healthcare obligations. In some instances these obligations dwarf the current expenditures on the current employees in those agencies. Unfortunately, our nation’s and many states’ elected officials have refused to address these issues, preferring to “kick the can down the road”, or at least have attempted to delay until they are out of office. So our nation and states now stand at a crossroads in terms of our fiscal health and must ask the questions “to tax or to cut”.

While spending cuts and tax cuts seem to be very popular with those who believe that the government is already too large and needs to be scaled back significantly, the challenge will be to arrive at a political solution to this problem. However, the problem runs deeper than simply cutting taxes or spending. Our tax structure is highly inefficient, not in the sense that funds are lost or that there are too many tax collectors, but in the sense that the tax system encourages behavior that would not otherwise occur.

According to the Tax Foundation, Americans spend nearly 20 cents for every dollar collected in taxes on tax compliance. This tax compliance includes completing tax forms, seeking tax planning and filling out other paperwork.   According to the CATO institute, the cost of tax compliance is nearly 2 percent of Gross Domestic Product, or roughly $265 billion.

The complexity of the tax code not only interferes with economic planning, but has also fostered an entire industry segment that has devoted itself to assisting firms and individuals in aggressively avoiding taxes.

Moreover, due to the complex nature of the tax codes, these firms are able to exploit the loopholes which in turn push Congress to act to close those loopholes, which then creates more loopholes and the cycle goes on.

While our tax system is highly complex, the way government spends and allocates funds to achieve its goals is much more complex and perhaps inefficient. A recent Government Accounting Office (GAO) report finds that numerous federal agencies perform similar if not duplicative duties and have identical programs. According to the report, there are nearly three dozen agencies and sub-agencies in which there are duplicate and/or fragmented programs.  The agencies range from agriculture to defense to social services.  While many elected officials are bemoaning the excessive waste that is inherent in the federal government, the fact of the matter is that the report indicates that $100 billion to $200 billion is duplicative spending. Out of a $3.4 trillion budget, this duplicative spending amounts to less than 1 percent of the total budget.

It is clear the current tax system is a drag on the economy. Perhaps more tax revenue could be collected with a simplified tax code. In addition, how funds and programs are disbursed within the federal government can be characterized as inefficient. However, many elected officials want to avoid addressing these problems and go directly to cutting programs and cutting taxes as to avoid upsetting their constituencies. One of the roles of economists is to assist society in identifying efficient allocations of scarce resources among various competing interests. From this economist’s point of view, our current tax system and the waste within government needs be addressed before we decide to change our taxes or spending.


Are We There Yet? 2011 Economic Outlook Conference Wrap-Up

February 28, 2011

Raquel Frye

It’s a new year and a chance for us to present our yearly outlook for the economy. The Regional Economic Studies Institute (RESI) hosted its 14th annual Economic Outlook Conference on February 16, 2011 at the BWI Hilton Hotel.  As in years past, the conference provided a platform to present RESI’s economic overview and forecast. The theme for this year’s conference was Are We There Yet? The phrase—commonly used by kids during long car trips—highlighted the question mark surrounding the economic recovery and our eagerness to finally bounce back from the woes that have afflicted over the last three years.

There are many indicators that help us gauge whether the economy is back on track and while many continue to show signs of distress (i.e. the labor market) the road ahead is looking a lot brighter than it was a year ago.  While we may not be “there” just yet, at least we know that we are not headed in the opposite direction anymore.  If you are interested in seeing the presentation and getting a little more detail please see this link.

As I indicated during my last post, this year, RESI participated in a crowd-sourcing activity that involved getting feedback from attendees regarding what they would do if they had power over fiscal, monetary and housing policies.   The top answers submitted by attendees were revealed family feud style.   In my opinion, it was a great opportunity to learn about what people feel are the best ways to tackle the significant challenges that we are facing. 

In addition to DECO staff, the program was composed of several other distinguished guests.  For instance, Robert Hannon, President and CEO of Anne Arundel Economic Development Corporation welcomed us to Anne Arundel County with some facts and jokes.  Following the outlook presentation, Kathleen Snyder, President and CEO of the Maryland Chamber of Commerce gave us an overview of this year’s legislative session and the bills that the Chamber was supporting and opposing.  Last but not least, David Beck, Senior Vice President and Regional Executive and Robert Carpenter, Lead Financial Economist both from the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond gave a very educational presentation about the Reserve’s dual mandate of promoting price stability and full employment.  They began their segment by giving a broad overview of the Reserve’s policy options and provided data and graphs to illustrate how the Fed’s balance sheet has evolved since the beginning of the recession. 

While I thoroughly enjoyed all the speakers that day, my favorite people that day were a group of extremely bright students.   As a special treat, we had several members of an AP Economics course from Arundel High School in attendance.  As someone who cares about economics education, I was delighted to see a group of students who seemed so genuinely interested in the presentations and eager to ask eloquent and thought-provoking questions.  I can only hope that we’ll be seeing these young people joining the ranks of economists in the near future!


VIDEO: We Want You!

February 3, 2011

Raquel

To give us your opinion!  Have you ever fantasized about what policies you would put in place in order to get the economy rolling again?  No?! Perhaps it’s something that only we economists like to do in our spare time.  I know I have plenty of ideas and suggestions.

Of course, it’s easy to be an armchair quarterback when it comes to difficult decisions but I think having an open dialogue where ideas and policies are challenged and discussed is extremely important.   In order for policies to have a shot at being successful, they should not be formed in a vacuum far from the people who must deal with the repercussions on a daily basis.

As part of our Economic Outlook Conference this year, we are asking your opinion and we really want to hear it!  You know what they say – sharing is caring. When you register for the conference, please take a few minutes to fill out three brief questions. Your answers will be gathered and shared during the conference in a fun way (hint: it will involve audience participation).   Here are the questions as they appear on our conference page:

  • If you were in charge, what policies/programs/legislation would you put in place to lower unemployment?
  • If you were in charge what policies/programs/legislation would you put in place to lower the deficit?
  • How would you address the challenges facing the real estate market from underwater mortgages to the shadow inventory of homes?”

Even if you can’t attend this year’s conference (which is unfortunate) we are still seeking your input  You can submit your responses right away—HERE!

Check out what some local experts “would do” if they were in charge.

 

Hope to see you all at the Economic Outlook Conference on February 16th!


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.